std::counting_semaphore limiting concurrent connections

openConnection() is called by 10 threads concurrently, but the service must never have more than 4 connections open at once. Using std::counting_semaphore<8> initialized to 4 as shown, what behavior does this actually produce, and how does it differ fundamentally from guarding the same code with a plain std::mutex?

main.cpp
std::counting_semaphore<8> connectionSlots(4);   // supports >= 8 permits, starts with 4

void openConnection(int id) {
    connectionSlots.acquire();          // blocks if 4 permits are already taken
    doNetworkWork(id);                  // at most 4 of these run concurrently
    connectionSlots.release();          // frees one permit back up
}

// 10 threads each call openConnection(id) once

41 of 51 in Concurrency